social issues
As Nature Made Him: The Boy Who Was Raised as a Girl by John Colapinto
In
As Nature Made Him,
John Colapinto tells David Reimer’s story of being born as a physically
normal baby boy whose circumcision (a practice that is increasingly being
questioned as needing to be “routine”) went wrong, resulting in the loss
of his penis. In the mid-1960s
there weren’t many surgical options available to David’s parents, and
they were ashamed of what had become of their son.
Through a program on Canadian television, the Reimers came into
contact with Dr. John Mahoney, a pioneer in the field of sexual identity and
leader at Johns Hopkins Hospital. Through
meeting with Dr. Mahoney, it was decided that David would undergo castration
as a baby and be raised as a girl, with further surgery to follow when he
became a teenager. John
Colapinto has done a lot of research into this case, and explains the many
sides of the story and how the results of the case incorrectly became an
example of successful childhood sexual reassignment.
The variety and thoroughness of interviews and factual material make As
Nature Made Him a very
worthwhile and thought-provoking read.
Broken
Silence: Voices of Japanese Feminism
edited by Sandra Buckley
Reading
Broken Silence made me want to learn more about the history of
Japan and even more specifically, about the role of the US after the
bombings during WWII. Wanting
to educate Westerners about feminism in Japan, Sandra Buckley set about
interviewing eleven prominent and diverse Japanese feminists including
Aoki Yayoi, Ueno Chizuko, and Matsui Yayori.
Each interview is accompanied by an introduction or biography
about each feminist, as well as a sample of their writing or works.
Topics of interest to me included honorifics and analysis of
gendered syntactic in the Japanese language, arranged marriages and how
they shape sexuality for Japanese men and women, the dependency on
prostitution and the conditions suffered by those working in the sex
industry, and the minikomi system of underground feminist press and
literature. Also included
are an extensive timeline of Japanese feminism, a glossary, and a
listing of feminist organizations.
This collection is very thoughtful and diverse.
Critical
Mass: Bicycling’s Defiant Celebration edited by Chris Carlsson
I’ve
never lived in a town with a Critical Mass movement, but have always
been curious about it. It’s
a spontaneous bike ride without leaders that takes place at regular
intervals in cities all over the world.
The largest masses are in San Francisco, where the phenomenon
originated in the early 1990s. There’s
a lot of conflict surrounding Critical Mass because the bikes often
block car traffic at busy times, which irritates motorists and attracts
police presence. But to the participants, it’s often simply a time to enjoy
biking among the safety of many other bike riders.
The essays in this collection discuss the many aspects of
Critical Mass, and how it works across the US and the rest of the world.
I particularly enjoyed all the reprinted flyers, photographs, and
zine entries that brought this documentation together.
The Culture of Make
Believe by Derrick Jensen
Derrick
Jensen’s last book, A Language Older Than Words, hit me very
hard; it was painfully honest, making it difficult to read, yet
necessary to finish. The
Culture of Make Believe was much the same way, but this time I knew
what to expect on an emotional level, at least.
Derrick analyzes the many different kinds of hatred people
experience, and then goes on to link up all the results of these
feelings and actions. He
connects everything from crimes committed by singular humans,
governments, and corporations, including the rape and abuse of women and
children, to historical incidents like the Holocaust, lynchings,
slavery, the slaughter of Native Americans, and the destruction of the
Earth and its many species. He
includes many conversations with other activists and friends, as well as
a lot of research to prove his points and theories.
Derrick’s point is that we (all humans) must understand and
accept our actions and all their far-reaching effects in order to
salvage any kind of future for our species and environment.
Despite Everything: A
Cometbus Omnibus by Aaron Cometbus
For
those of you who haven’t heard of Cometbus, it’s one of the
longest running, best known, and most always loved punk zines available.
Despite Everything is a mammoth 600-page hand
cramp-producing compilation of excerpts that Aaron selected from the
issues over the years. It
includes pieces from back when Cometbus was more
contributor-based and focused on music, lots of Aaron’s travel
writings, and his interesting reports and histories of topics such as
the underground press and the Gilman St. venue.
Despite Everything is extremely impressive, in that Aaron
has stuck with the zine for so long and he’s been able to produce and
publish such a high volume of material worth reading.
Some of my favorite comments that Aaron makes are that nowhere is
too far to walk, and that you should appear in public for at least some
time every day.
Detour:
My Bipolar Road Trip in 4-D
by Lizzie Simon
At
23, Lizzie is leaving her job as an award-winning producer at a hot NYC
theater and going on a quest to find others like herself.
Just before college, Lizzie was diagnosed as bipolar as a result
of a severe period of depression and mania.
Her aim is to find other young folks who are bipolar and
successful in their lives, not simply just surviving or coping with
being bipolar. Detour
is a difficult book to describe, but Lizzie’s writing and descriptions
are very clear and instantly drew me into her life and need to find a
common bond with others. She’s
able to describe what it’s like to be bipolar, and through
interviewing others she sheds a lot of light on this disease that had
previously been a mystery to me. Hopefully
her words will help dissolve some of the stereotypes about mental
illnesses and the many people living with them.
Disposable
People: The New Slavery in the Global Economy
by Kevin Bales
The most impressive feature of Disposable
People to me was the level
of accuracy and accountability that the author, Kevin Bales, held
himself to. Instead of
simply using the statistics about modern slavery that are available from
groups like Anti-Slavery International, he used them as a basis, then
did a lot of field and statistical research to determine his own
slightly more conservative estimates.
Though the subject matter is extremely disturbing and depressing,
Disposable People
is very readable and presents a clear picture of the various types of
slavery that exist today, along with personal stories from some of the
areas where slavery is more common (Thailand, Pakistan, Brazil,
Mauritania, and India). By
understanding the conditions that allow slavery to exist we can move
toward ending it, and Kevin Bales analyzes the steps we need to take to
accomplish that.
Fat
Land: How Americans Became the Fattest People in the World
by Greg Critser
Taking
a look around, it’s obvious how relevant Fat Land is, as over
20 percent of Americans are obese and many more are moving in that
direction. The reasons for
this are varied, and Greg Critser brings them to light and draws the
connections to government regulations, myths about exercise and fitness,
the growing availability of fast food, increased portion sizes, school
food programs, and, of course, corporate America’s role in all of
this. He also looks closely
at the results of our country’s growing obesity, including diabetes
and other health problems, the cost of treating these diseases, and the
effects on the morals of Americans.
Overall, I enjoyed Fat Land, but I did think that a few
places were a little boring and repetitive.
Of course, I also read most of this book while on a plane and my
attention wasn’t at its peak! My
favorite parts were learning about how the rise of high fructose corn
syrup began, and the critique of the public school system.
Going Up the River: Travels in a Prison Nation by Joseph T. Hallinan
Although it’s not that well known, super-maximum security prisons (“supermax”)
cost a fortune to build and many towns are fighting to get one.
Joseph T. Hallinan spent four years traveling around the US in an
attempt to report and understand this trend and many other issues surrounding
the state of our prisons. He
focuses on the financial side of this multi-million dollar industry, including
the involvement of private corporations, individual prison budgets, and the
prison transportation system. At
a time when many people are questioning if our prisons are working, Going
Up the River actually has some answers about the penal system we’ve
created.
If I Live to Be 100:
Lessons From the Centenarians by Neenah Ellis
Neenah
Ellis is a former staff producer on NPR’s All Things Considered,
and If I Live to Be 100 came as a result of a piece she did for All
Things Considered called One Hundred Years of Stories.
The book details Neenah’s struggle to complete the piece for
NPR as a result of the many obstacles she encountered while interviewing
centenarians, both in her personal abilities and the physical and
emotional impairments of the centenarians.
After taking a long break from reading books (due to an influx of
zines and other non-reading distractions), this was the first one I
picked up. I wanted to read
something that wasn’t difficult or too heavy in subject matter, yet
personal. Not very high
expectations, I realize, but If I Live to Be 100 met them
all and got me back into my reading mode.
And it also made me wish that I spent more time with older
people.
A Language Older Than Words by Derrick Jensen
Honestly,
I don’t have enough kind words to describe this book.
Derrick Jensen writes about the land and environment, humans and
animals, abuse, communication, and responsibility.
Many ideas, stories, and truths are presented and then connections are
made, sometimes slowly and sometimes in groups, but always logically.
A Language is often very personal and open, yet often dark, as
the author reveals his realities. This
book provoked me to do a lot of self-evaluation and to rethink some times in
my past. Derrick Jensen has done
an amazing job of showing the relationship between all living things and how
our society rejects this relationship. Please
read A Language Older Than Words.
The Mole People by Jennifer Toth
Jennifer Toth uses her skills as a reporter to uncover the mystery of the “mole
people,” the people thought to be living in the network of tunnels and train
systems that run below NYC. Despite
denial of their existence by the police and many social workers, Jennifer
gains entrance to their communities and is able to conduct many personal
interviews with people who have either chosen or been forced into this
lifestyle. She discovers that
there are possibly thousands of people living up to seven stories underground
with amenities such as running water, electricity, and community watch
systems. I felt very sympathetic
toward these houseless people and am thankful that Jennifer took so many risks
to bring us this book.
Prison
Madness: The Mental Health Crisis Behind Bars and What We Must Do About
It by Terry Kupers, M.D.
Dr.
Kupers writes from the perspective of a psychiatrist and professor who
has testified in many class action suits about the conditions and the
mental health services available in jails and prisons.
In Prison Madness
he explains how many people who enter prisons are already mentally ill,
or have the strong possibility of becoming mentally ill due to the
conditions existing in prisons, including isolation, overcrowding,
violence and rape, and racism. The
mental health systems in these institutions aren’t equipped to help
prisoners in any way other than possibly providing them with
anti-psychotic medications in severe cases.
The bottom line is that people are being abused in prisons and
are emerging from prison, back into society, in much worst shape and are
more violent and angry than ever. Dr. Kupers in no way suggests that mentally ill prisoners
shouldn’t be fairly sentenced and imprisoned, instead he lays out
several plans and changes that need to take place to improve the current
situation. Living in Texas,
surrounded by prisons, and hearing of current financial cutbacks to our
correctional facilities, this book was of much interest to me.
At the risk of being repetitive, Dr. Kupers makes his point by
offering many examples and quotes from prisoners and prison staff.
Though this book is a few years old, I was surprised that he only
brought up the effects of the prison-industrial complex in the closing
chapter. Overall, Prison
Madness is an eye opener if you have any thoughts about rehabilitative programs
existing inside prisons.
Riding
the Bus With My Sister
by Rachel Simon
In
Riding the Bus With My Sister,
Rachel, a writer and college professor, comes to spend parts of a year
riding city buses with her sister Beth.
Beth has mild mental retardation and lives alone in a city away
from her family. She
isn’t particularly close to them because they really don’t
understand or support her lifestyle, which mainly consists of riding the
buses, eating junk foods, and dressing in extremely bright clothing.
Rachel interweaves their family history and explains how she
feels about Beth, how she struggles with her feelings about Beth, and
how she doesn’t even understand or know exactly what it means that
Beth is mentally retarded. So
by riding the buses, meeting Beth’s friends, and sharing her world,
Rachel comes to understand Beth and even learns something about herself
in the process. Riding
the Bus With My Sister is
definitely a feel-good kind of book, but with a serious purpose that
will hopefully make us look upon strangers and people with differences
with more compassion.
Slut!: Growing up Female with a Bad Reputation by Leora Tanenbaum
Leora
Tanenbaum shares her own story of being labeled, as well as the stories of
many other women and girls. She also provides many recent legal cases, examples from
popular culture, and even explores the history and use of the word slut and
similar terms. Since women of
various ages are interviewed, the immediate and long-term effects of
developing and living with a bad reputation are explored.
The main thing that struck me while reading Slut! was how
often other girls start and continue these name calling events, often in an
attempt to direct attention away from themselves.
It’s too bad that women can’t stick together and openly accept
each other’s sexual practices as readily as we accept those of men.
Stiff: The Curious
Lives of Human Cadavers
by Mary Roach
Though
the subject matter of Stiff
may sound morbid, Mary Roach’s writing allows her natural curiosity
and humorous personality to shine through.
I was most impressed with the research done for Stiff
and felt that not much could have been overlooked, both in the past and
present uses of cadavers. Some
of the uses for cadavers include: practicing surgery, dissection, test
subjects for impact tests, forensic studies to aid in solving crimes,
figuring out the cause of airplane crashes, testing bullets and bombs,
and other military uses. Also, Mary finds out about embalming, cremation, and even
newer ways to dispose of or preserve bodies, and the many crazy things
that humans have done to the deceased over the ages.
Overall, Stiff
is the most interesting science related book that I’ve read in quite
some time. Be sure to check
out the footnotes, because there are some particularly amusing ones in
there.
Waist
High In the World: A Life Among the Nondisabled by Nancy Mairs
Nancy
Mairs is a straightforward and honest writer who tackles the many issues
surrounding living her life with a disability.
She has degenerative MS and has spent the past ten years in a
wheelchair, needing a lot of physical care to make it through her daily
routines. In Waist High
In the World, Nancy examines the proper terminologies used for
people with disabilities and explains why she prefers to call herself a
cripple. She also discusses sexuality, her mental health, suicide,
architecture, and building techniques that don’t allow access to
people using wheelchairs. Another
part I found interesting was her involvement with the police, going
undercover to bust a drug scam that was taking advantage of people like
herself. The most
interesting and useful aspects to me were Nancy’s suggestions on how
to be an ally to people with disabilities and how to effectively assist
them in public situations.
Waste and Want: A Social History of Trash by Susan Strasser
With the third book in her study of consumer culture,
Susan Strasser takes an in-depth look at one of the less appealing aspects of
the American way of life – our massive production of garbage.
To me, the most interesting part of this book was the beginning, where
it explains the amount of recycling and reuse of every imaginable substance
that occurred in the nineteenth century.
The progression away from these practices is logically and clearly
detailed as manufacturing equipment, labor, and raw materials become
available. All the while,
Americans are being convinced that “new” and “disposable” products are
the key to a future filled with happiness, convenience, and luxury.
Waste and Want presents all of this information in a direct and
unassuming manner.
Wuhu Diary: On Taking My Adopted Daughter Back to Her Hometown in China by Emily Prager
Emily Prager (novelist and professor at NYU) tells the story of
adopting LuLu as a baby and returning with her to China when LuLu is five
years old. During their two
months in China, they spend much time in Wuhu where LuLu was born.
Emily Prager’s descriptions of Wuhu and its many delights are as
accurate as is her ability to describe the range of emotions she and LuLu
experience while searching for LuLu’s place of birth and other clues about
her past. Adoption has always
been a subject I’ve been curious about and reading this story really shows
how much love is possible between any mother and child, despite biological
and cultural differences.
Younger Than That Now by Jeff Durstewitz and Ruth Williams
This book is more than just a compilation of letters exchanged between Jeff
and Ruth. They have gone back and
filled in the whole story, supplemented by the letters they wrote, starting
with the year 1969 when they were both high school students.
Throughout the book, Jeff, from liberal NY, and Ruth, from conservative
Mississippi, fight their way through stereotypes, the civil rights movement,
and the sexual revolution as they gradually mature.
I was particularly interested in reading about Ruth’s involvement
with the communist movement during the 1970s.
In all, their adventures and experiences make for an interesting tale
of our times.
Home
Weblog
News Order
Writings Booklist
Zines Links